One of the things I both love and hate about research is that you often stumble across extra information that can take you down a bit of a rabbit hole. It takes a lot of focus and self control to remain on track. However, anyone who knows me knows I was diagnosed with ADHD 10 years ago, so off down the rabbit hole I went.
In my research I came upon a study of 22 Thoroughbreds from Hong Kong Jockey Club that were destined for euthanasia for reasons other than back pain. In this study they discovered that not only did all of the specimens have Kissing Spine, but that all specimens showed atrophy of the Multifidus muscle. Moreover, it appeared that the spinous processes were overlaying on the same side as the smaller or weaker multifidus muscle. The study concluded that while more research needed to be done, it was likely that the role of the multifidus muscle had significant implications in the development of kissing spines. The final sentence in the study says “The fact that atrophy of multifidus persisted in association with chronic pathological lesions suggests that in horses, as in man, there is a potential need for physiotherapeutic strategies for strengthening and recruiting this muscle during treatment and rehabilitation.” (Stubbs, et al; 2010)
Physiotherapy for treatment and rehabilitation. But what about just for training? What can we do to bring multifidus up to par so that it can support the horses spine, not just in rehabilitation but in the entire training process to protect the spine and help to prevent kissing spine?
Anatomy of Multifidus
First let’s look at Multifidus, where it’s located and its role in the horses body.
Multifidus is in three parts. Cervical, Thoracic and Lumbar. The cervical portion of the muscle starts at C2 and extends to C7, attaching to the superior articular process of C4-C7 and inserting on the lateral aspect and tips of the spinous processes of C2-C5. The Thoracic portion originates from the transverse processes of the thoracic vertebrae and insert on the spinous processes at varied levels above their point of origin. The lumbar multifidus originates from the posterior surface of the sacrum and some parts also originate in the iliac spine of the ilium. Running through the groove between the spinous and transverse processes, multifidus overlies the laminae of cervical and thoracic vertebrae and the posterior surface of the sacrum. Multifidus runs deep to (underneath) Longissimus Dorsi.
That’s a lot of big words and unless you’re particularly familiar with anatomy, it’s probably confusing. So let me simplify it a little.
It runs almost the entire length of the horses body, from the top of the neck to their butt. And you know all the sticky-outy bits on all the vertebrae? Well multifidus attaches on to all of those. It is literally the spines stabiliser.
Think of it like a building structure. The spine is the framing; multifidus is the bracing that holds the framing in place.
In short, it’s a really, REALLY important muscle.
With all of this in mind, it stands to reason that we would want to ensure that multifidus is as strong and healthy as possible. And guess what, you don’t have to wait until your horse is broken to be able to fix it. In fact, the exercises to strengthen multifidus are so safe, easy and simple that you can start doing this with your young horses before they’re started under saddle, you can do them with a horse already in work and you can do them with retired horses too.
Developing the Multifidus muscle
For the following information I sourced three separate studies. The studies presented similar information, similar methods and similar results. The information below is a culmination of the information from all three studies.
The 3 studies ran for 12 weeks (Tabor, 2015), 3 months (Stubbs, et al, 2011) and 90 days (Rodrigues, et al:2023); essentially, they all ran for the same amount of time. Two of the studies suggested repeating the exercises 5 days per week (Stubbs, et al, 2011 and Tabor 2015), while Rodrigues, et al (2023) suggested 3 times per week on alternating days. All studies suggested repeating the exercises 5 times each, holding each for 5 seconds. There was variation of the exercises between the studies. This is a list of ALL of the exercises that were listed over the three studies. Exercises are performed by luring the horse with a treat such as a carrot, not a forced flexion; stretching exercises are manual movement or manipulation.
Prior to performing these exercises, you should warm up your horse with a 5-10 minute walk and trot on the lunge or in hand.
Lunging for 5-10 minutes to warm up your horse.
Mobilisation exercises:
1. Chin to chest.
2. Chin to between carpi/upper front legs.
3. Chin to between front fetlocks.
Chin to between front fetlocks.
4. Neck Extension (no photo)
5. Lateral flexion to girth (left and right)
5. Lateral flexion to point of hip (left and right)
6. Lateral flexion to tarsus/hock (left and right)
7. Sternum lift (no photo)
8. Fore leg stretch forward (left and right)
9. Hind leg stretch forward (left and right)
10. Hindquarter disengagement (left and right, 5-10 steps each direction)
HQ disengagement
Additional work
Some additional stretches that I would suggest but are not included in the studies would be the Hammock Stretch and the pelvic tilt.
Hammock Stretch
These two movements can help to activate and stretch the multifidus muscle at its caudal (close to the tail) end.
I have provided photographic examples of all of these exercises except for neck extension, sternum lift and pelvic tilt.
Following these exercises alone with no other exercises, the 2 of the studies showed that they can increase the size of multifidus by as much as 1.8cm2 in just 3 months. The third study was on Thoroughbred race horses in work with a control group that did not do the exercises and an experiment group that performed the exercises as well as their daily workout. The studies also showed an increase in symmetry of the multifidus.
Troubleshooting:
My horse won’t stand still, what do I do?
There are a few reasons a horse won’t stand still. They don’t understand the idea of just following the treat. You can teach them this by breaking down the task into smaller pieces. Move the treat in small increments. You can add a verbal cue such as “Here” or “Touch” which cues them to seek where the hand is and touch their nose to it. Another reason they may not stand still is because they are not balanced enough in their body. You can help them with this by standing them next to a fence. Always allow them a way out so they don’t feel trapped. With them standing next to the fence, ask for small flexions. You don’t have to go the whole hog right from the get go. If your horse is stiff or unbalanced, they’re going to find some of this really hard. Break it down and expand on it.
My horse lifts their hind leg when I ask them to flex to their hock, how do I stop that?
Ok, don’t freak out. They’re probably not trying to kick you. In order to get more flexion, they’re lifting their inside leg to throw more weight to the outside hind so they can more easily reach around. Essentially, they’re cheating. Bring the treat back to a place they can reach it without having to lift their leg to get the bend.
References
Rodrigues, P.G; Fidencio, C. F; Oliveira, K.D; Silva, C.M; Oliveira, C.G; Carvalho, J.M.O; Santos, A.D.F; Oliveria Junior, G.M.D; and Souza, J.C.D (2023) “Functional training promotes benefits in the physical condition of horses,” Turkish Journal of Veterinary & Animal Sciences: Vol. 47: No. 6, Article 6.
Stubbs, N.C., Riggs, C.M., Hodges, P.W., Jeffcott, L.B., Hodgson, D.R., Clayton, H.M and McGowan, C.M (2010) Osseous spinal pathology and epaxial muscle ultrasonography in Thoroughbred racehorses. Equine Veterinary Journal. Equine vet. J. (2010) 42 (Suppl. 38) 654-661
Stubbs, N.C; Kaiser, L.J; Hauptman, J. and Clayton, H.M (2011) Dynamic mobilisation exercises increase cross sectional area of musculus multifidus. Equine Veterinary Journal. Equine vet. J. (2011) 43 (5) 522-529
Tabor, G. (2015) The effect of dynamic mobilisation exercises on the equine multifidus muscle and thoracic profile. Thesis. University of Plymouth. Retrieved from https://pearl.plymouth.ac.uk/fose-thesesother/145
Kissing spine is one of the most commonly discussed and perhaps most misunderstood causes of back pain in horses.
Some horses buck. Some become girthy, refuse transitions or object violently to being ridden. Others continue working, competing and apparently doing everything asked of them despite significant changes being visible on X-ray.
That has led to a familiar phrase:
“Ride the horse, not the X-ray.”
But there is a serious problem with using that phrase to justify continued ridden work.
A horse’s failure to demonstrate pain is not proof that pain doesn’t exist.
Horses cannot tell us how much something hurts. Pain expression varies between individuals, and horses can actively reduce observable discomfort behaviours when humans are present.
In one study of hospitalised orthopaedic patients, observable discomfort behaviours fell by an average of 77.4% when a caretaker approached. In 30% of horses, those behaviours stopped altogether until the person left.[1]
So when a horse has significant pathological changes in its spine but continues to comply under saddle, there are two very different conclusions we could draw:
“The horse isn’t showing us that it hurts.”
or:
“The horse isn’t hurting.”
Science currently allows us to say the first.
It does not necessarily allow us to say the second.
That distinction should matter enormously when deciding whether we continue sitting on that horse’s back.
What Is Kissing Spine?
The condition commonly called kissing spine involves abnormally close, impinging or overriding dorsal spinous processes.
The dorsal spinous processes are the bony projections extending upwards from the vertebral column. In a healthy spine there is space between each of the spinous processes.
With kissing spine, those spaces become narrowed. As the condition progresses, the processes may touch, impinge or overlap.
Changes visible on imaging can include:
narrowing between adjacent processes;
bone-to-bone contact;
sclerosis or increased bone density;
radiolucent areas (look brighter/whiter on x-ray) and osteolysis;
reactive bone formation;
remodelling of the processes; and
overriding or overlapping processes.
The area beneath the saddle particularly the middle and caudal thoracic spine is commonly affected.
It’s important to note that there is a difference between closely spaced spinous processes and established pathological bony change.
A narrow space is not automatically equivalent to advanced kissing spine.
However, when repeated contact between the bones has produced sclerosis, osteolysis, remodelling or other visible changes to the bone itself, we are no longer simply looking at two bones that happen to sit relatively close together. We are looking at boney tissue that has responded to abnormal mechanical forces.
How Does Kissing Spine Present?
There is no single classic presentation.
Physical signs may include:
back sensitivity or pain on palpation;
muscle spasm;
poor topline development;
asymmetrical musculature;
hollowing through the back;
difficulty lifting the thorax and back;
restricted spinal movement;
altered hindlimb movement;
difficulty engaging the abdominal musculature;
reduced performance;
stiffness;
recurrent unexplained lameness; and
secondary sacroiliac or limb problems.
Based on the above list of physical signs, does this horse look like he has kissing spine?
Behaviour may be equally important.
Behavioural signs can include:
girthiness;
resentment of grooming;
moving away during saddling;
refusing to stand at the mounting block;
ears pinned during mounting;
tail swishing;
reluctance to go forward;
rushing;
bucking;
rearing;
kicking out;
resistance to contact;
difficulty maintaining canter;
problems with transitions;
cross-cantering;
refusing fences;
rushing fences; and
a previously willing horse becoming anxious, defensive or resistant.
None of these signs individually equates to kissing spine. They can occur with numerous painful conditions.
But neither should they automatically be labelled behavioural, naughty, lazy or training problems until pain has been properly investigated.
What About Horses That Show No Signs?
Radiographic changes associated with kissing spine have been identified in horses described as having no recognised clinical signs of back pain.
This is sometimes interpreted as evidence that kissing spine does not necessarily hurt. That is NOT what those findings demonstrate.
They demonstrate that radiographic abnormalities can exist without investigators identifying clinical signs that they attribute to back pain.
Those are not the same thing.
Pain is a subjective experience. A horse cannot self-report it.
We therefore infer pain from things we can observe:
behaviour;
posture;
facial expression;
palpation responses;
lameness;
physiological measurements;
performance changes; and
responses to analgesia.
Every one of those methods has limitations.
Research into equine discomfort has demonstrated that horses may dramatically suppress observable discomfort behaviour when a person approaches. Brief direct observation can therefore underestimate the discomfort a horse displays when left undisturbed.[1,2]
That makes the description “asymptomatic” potentially misleading.
A more accurate description is often:
“No recognised clinical signs of pain were identified.”
We know what we observed.
We cannot necessarily know what the horse experienced.
Horses Don’t Have to Scream Before We Listen
Horses evolved as prey animals. Showing weakness, injury or impaired movement carries a biological cost. Recognising equine pain can consequently be difficult.
This does not mean every horse deliberately hides every pain response. Nevertheless, expecting an animal to provide an unmistakable outward demonstration before we accept that something hurts is an unreliable model that could lead to serious welfare issues.
Individual responses to pain can vary. One horse may buck explosively. Another may pin its ears. Some may subtly alter their posture. Others may simply become less willing. Many may even continue doing everything asked of it.
Compliance is not proof of comfort.
A horse jumping a course is not proof that its back doesn’t hurt.
A horse performing a dressage test is not proof that its back doesn’t hurt.
A horse standing quietly to be saddled is not proof that its back doesn’t hurt.
A horse continuing to work despite significant pathology does not automatically give us permission to keep asking.
When Severe Disease Hides in Plain Sight: Even Keel
One of the cases behind Dressage Atlas’s position is the Thoroughbred Even Keel, known at home as Wiggle.
Even Keel raced in Hong Kong for three seasons. He was retired after injuring his right fore superficial digital flexor tendon and underwent rehabilitation before being exported to New Zealand.
His export veterinary report described him as:
“Sound for full work without exclusion.”
Once in New Zealand, however, he displayed a collection of apparently unrelated behaviours:
tongue poking;
head flicking and nose wiggling;
nappiness;
saddle aversion;
tail swishing;
difficulty bending to the right; and
resistance during saddling.
Each behaviour was given a plausible alternative explanation.
The tongue behaviour was attributed to his history of being tongue-tied. His head movements were blamed on allergies or dental discomfort. Saddle aversion was attributed to ulcers. His difficulty bending and nappiness were described as common ex-racehorse behaviour.
What struck us most is that he remained rideable.
He allowed people to saddle him. He carried a rider. He was generally obedient under saddle.
Even during his final lameness examination, he did not palpate obviously painful through the back. Because he flexed significantly lame through both hocks, the hocks initially appeared to be the most likely problem.
Radiographs told a profoundly different story.
Even Keel was diagnosed with Grade 4 kissing spine affecting approximately 80% of his spine.
The damage was so extensive that no reasonable treatment could restore him to comfortable function, and he was humanely euthanised.
This is one individual case, not a controlled scientific study. It demonstrates the diagnostic problem discussed throughout this article.
He had passed veterinary assessment.
He did not display an unmistakable response to back palpation.
He continued to permit ridden work.
His behaviours could individually be explained away.
Yet he had catastrophic spinal pathology.
Clinical examination alone had not identified it.
Radiography alone could not have described every aspect of his experience but without radiography, the structural disease would have remained hidden.
This is why the choice should never be framed as:
“Do we examine the horse or examine the X-ray?”
We need both.
Clinical examination tells us how the horse is functioning.
Diagnostic imaging tells us what cannot be seen from the outside.
Neither should be used to dismiss the other.
Does Radiographic Severity Matter?
Yes; although imaging must still be interpreted as part of the whole horse.
A major study involving 582 horses investigated relationships between clinical back pain, radiographic abnormalities and nuclear scintigraphy of the thoracolumbar spine.
The researchers found significant associations between higher radiographic grades and thoracolumbar pain. Scintigraphic abnormalities were also associated with clinical pain.[3]
The fact that radiographic changes and observable pain do not correlate perfectly does not mean radiographic pathology is meaningless.
It means our ability to recognise pain and identify its exact source is imperfect.
This horse demonstrates the opposite problem to the quiet horse with dramatic radiographic changes: apparently minor changes on X-Ray accompanied by extreme adverse behaviour. The image cannot tell us whether the visible changes were the sole cause, but it reinforces that radiographic severity and pain expression do not always correspond.
When imaging demonstrates actual contact accompanied by sclerosis, osteolysis, remodelling or overlapping processes, the abnormality deserves more consideration than whether the horse happens to buck when mounted.
Kissing Spine in Thoroughbred Racehorses
Kissing-spine-type changes appear to be particularly common in Thoroughbred racehorses.
In a post-mortem study of 36 Thoroughbreds that died or were euthanised at Californian racetracks, Haussler and colleagues found impingement of the dorsal spinous processes in 92% of specimens.
Degenerative changes affecting the thoracolumbar articular processes occurred in 97%, while every specimen showed degeneration of the lumbar intertransverse joints and sacroiliac articulations. Some changes were both severe and widespread.[4]
A smaller radiographic study of 30 Chilean Thoroughbreds also found radiographic changes consistent with kissing spine throughout the population examined.
Stallions and mares averaged four affected dorsal spinous processes, while geldings averaged 3.5. The most significant changes occurred around T14–T16; the region situated beneath the rider and saddle.[5]
These studies demonstrate that spinal impingement and wider degenerative spinal pathology can be extraordinarily prevalent in some racing populations.
This matters when racehorses are retired into second careers.
A horse may leave racing because of a tendon injury, poor performance or another immediately apparent problem while substantial spinal pathology remains undiscovered.
If that horse is assumed to be suitable for ridden retraining without appropriate investigation, its reluctance, stiffness or defensive behaviour may be blamed on its temperament, racing history or inadequate retraining.
The horse may be labelled:
nappy;
girthy;
cold-backed;
difficult to bend;
resistant to the saddle;
anxious;
unwilling to go forward; or
simply a “typical ex-racehorse”.
None of those labels explain why the behaviour exists.
High prevalence does not make pathology harmless. It makes careful investigation more important.
What Causes Kissing Spine?
There is unlikely to be one single cause.
Potential contributing factors include:
individual anatomy and conformation;
developmental factors;
genetic susceptibility;
abnormal spinal loading;
poor muscular development;
inadequate trunk stability;
chronic hollow or extended posture;
inappropriate training;
poorly fitting saddles;
trauma;
hindlimb lameness;
sacroiliac dysfunction;
forelimb problems; and
compensatory movement resulting from pain elsewhere.
The relationship can work in both directions. Pain elsewhere can change the way the horse moves its back. Back pain can change how the horse loads its limbs.
This creates the potential for a cycle:
pain → altered movement → muscular dysfunction → abnormal loading → further pain
This is one reason simply treating the visible spinal lesion without investigating the rest of the horse can fail.
Genetics May Also Matter
Training and management may influence spinal loading, but kissing spine should not automatically be treated as something a rider has created.
A 2022 genome-wide association study examined 155 Stock-type and Warmblood horses that had been clinically and radiographically graded from unaffected to severe kissing spine.
Researchers identified a genetic marker associated with increasing kissing-spine grade and a candidate region on equine chromosome 25.[6]
The findings were preliminary. They cannot yet predict the outcome for an individual horse, and the study did not examine Thoroughbreds.
They did, however, support the likelihood that some horses carry greater inherited susceptibility.
Development is therefore most likely to be multifactorial.
Genetics may influence the anatomical foundation. Growth, conformation, nutrition, muscular development, training, injury and spinal loading may then influence how, or whether, that susceptibility develops into significant disease.
Correct work may reduce avoidable loading and improve spinal support. It cannot guarantee that a genetically susceptible horse will never develop kissing spine.
Dr Audrey DeClue and Kissing Spine
Veterinarian Dr Audrey DeClue has devoted considerable attention to kissing spine through The Horse First podcast and her work with sport horses.
Her approach is particularly interesting because she examines kissing spine beyond the narrow question of modern ridden horses.
In her 2023 episode Kissing Spine in Sport Horses, DeClue discusses comparable spinal pathology across an extraordinary range of species and time periods; including dogs, cats, humans, otters, horses and even dinosaurs.[7]
That has an important implication.
Kissing spine cannot simply be dismissed as a disease created by modern saddles, modern dressage or modern riding.
There is considerably more going on.
In Part Two, DeClue specifically examines whether kissing-spine lesions are painful and asks the provocative question:
“Do you ride the horse or the radiograph?”[8]
Her work is particularly relevant to the welfare problem surrounding horses with significant imaging findings but few outward signs.
Because absence of obvious resistance does not answer the fundamental question:
Does bone-on-bone pathology hurt the horse even when the horse continues to cooperate?
Diagnosing Kissing Spine
Diagnosis should never consist solely of taking one X-ray and declaring the horse’s back responsible for every problem it has.
A thorough veterinary investigation may include:
detailed history;
physical examination;
palpation;
dynamic assessment;
lameness examination;
ridden assessment where appropriate;
diagnostic analgesia;
radiography;
ultrasound;
nuclear scintigraphy; and
investigation of concurrent limb, pelvic or sacroiliac pathology.
Radiographs
Radiography allows veterinarians to examine the spacing and structure of the dorsal spinous processes.
It can identify narrowing, impingement, overlapping, sclerosis, osteolysis and remodelling.
Posture and neck position can influence the apparent spacing between processes, so images must be obtained and interpreted correctly.
Radiographs show structure. They do not directly measure the horse’s subjective experience of pain.
That does not make structural pathology irrelevant.
Nuclear scintigraphy
A bone scan can identify increased radiopharmaceutical uptake, providing information about active bone turnover.
This can be useful when several abnormalities are visible and the veterinarian is attempting to determine which areas are biologically active.
Diagnostic analgesia
Local anaesthetic may be used to determine whether blocking an area changes the horse’s movement, behaviour or performance.
But even this is not a perfect test.
The complex anatomy of the equine thoracolumbar spine can make it difficult to isolate one structure completely.
Diagnosis therefore requires judgement rather than one magic test.
An X-ray should not replace clinical examination.
Clinical examination should not be used as an excuse to avoid imaging when substantial spinal disease may be present.
Treatment
Treatment depends on the severity of the pathology, the individual horse and whether other painful conditions are present.
Options include:
rehabilitation;
veterinary pain management;
mesotherapy;
local medication;
interspinous ligament desmotomy; and
surgical removal or reshaping of affected bone.
But there is an important distinction:
Reducing pain temporarily is not necessarily the same thing as resolving the disease process that caused it.
Correct Work and Rehabilitation
Appropriate rehabilitation is an essential part of virtually every kissing-spine treatment programme.
The goal is not simply to make the horse fitter.
It is to improve how the horse supports and moves its spine.
Rehabilitation may include:
controlled walking;
appropriate mobilisation exercises;
groundwork;
in-hand exercises;
progressive pole work;
controlled hill work;
exercises developing trunk stability;
strengthening of the abdominal musculature; and
progressive rebuilding of the topline.
Where ridden work is considered appropriate by the horse’s veterinary team, it should only be introduced once the horse is comfortable and physically capable of supporting it.
Simply lunging endless circles is not rehabilitation.
Neither is forcing the horse’s head down in an attempt to make its back appear rounded.
Correct rehabilitation changes function, not merely outline.
Advantages
Rehabilitation can address muscular weakness and dysfunctional movement without surgery. It can also address contributing biomechanical problems throughout the body.
Limitations
Exercise cannot magically remove established pathological bone.
Rehabilitation requires time, consistency and close attention to the quality of movement.
Most importantly:
A painful horse cannot simply be exercised out of pain.
Multifidus: The Spine’s Deep Stabiliser
One of the most valuable findings in the racehorse research concerns the multifidus muscle.
Multifidus runs deeply alongside the vertebral column and provides segmental stability to the spine.
It acts less like a large movement-producing muscle and more like the bracing within a building: stabilising individual sections so the whole structure can function effectively.
In a study of 22 Hong Kong Thoroughbred racehorses presented for euthanasia for reasons other than back pain, every horse had measurable left-to-right multifidus asymmetry at more than two spinal levels.
Seventeen of the 22 horses had severe Grade 3 spinal pathology. Sixteen of those 17 showed multifidus or sacrocaudalis dorsalis atrophy on the same side as the more severe lesion. Increasing pathological severity was significantly associated with increasing muscle asymmetry.[9]
The study did not establish that all 22 horses had kissing spine.
The pathology included abnormalities affecting several spinal structures. Only one horse had overriding dorsal spinous processes recorded as its primary finding.
What the study demonstrated was a significant relationship between severe spinal pathology and localised atrophy of the muscles responsible for stabilising that region.
This creates another potential cycle:
spinal pathology → pain or altered muscle recruitment → multifidus atrophy → reduced spinal stability → further dysfunctional loading
Simply resolving pain—or surgically creating more space between the spinous processes—does not necessarily restore normal multifidus function.
That function must be rebuilt.
Can Multifidus Be Strengthened?
Yes.
A separate study followed eight unridden horses performing dynamic mobilisation exercises for three months.
The programme consisted of:
three cervical flexion exercises;
one cervical extension exercise; and
three lateral-bending exercises performed to both sides.
Each exercise was repeated five times per session, five days per week.
After three months, multifidus cross-sectional area had increased significantly on both sides at all six measured spinal levels between T10 and L5.
Left-to-right asymmetry also decreased.[10]
These exercises are commonly called carrot stretches, although they should be controlled mobilisation exercises rather than the horse simply twisting its neck as far as possible to obtain food.
They may include:
chin towards the chest;
chin between the forelegs;
chin towards the front fetlocks;
controlled extension forwards and upwards; and
lateral bending towards the girth, hip or hock.
The important point is not that carrot stretches cure kissing spine.
They do not remove established bone, reverse sclerosis or eliminate bone-on-bone contact.
Their value lies in recruiting and strengthening part of the muscular system responsible for supporting and stabilising the spine.
That makes them potentially valuable within preparation, prevention and rehabilitation—but never a justification for exercising a horse through unresolved pain.
Mesotherapy and Medical Treatment
Mesotherapy involves multiple small injections into the skin or superficial tissues across the affected region.
It is intended to influence pain signalling and reduce muscular pain or spasm.
Other veterinary treatments can include anti-inflammatory medication, local corticosteroid treatment, shockwave therapy and other pain-management strategies.
Advantages
Pain relief can allow a horse to move more normally and begin effective rehabilitation.
This matters because asking a painful horse to strengthen itself while the painful movement pattern remains active may simply reinforce compensation.
Limitations
Analgesia does not remove bone-on-bone contact.
It can reduce the experience or expression of pain without necessarily removing the underlying mechanical cause.
That distinction becomes especially important if pain relief is used primarily to allow a horse to continue being ridden.
Medical treatment should be part of a considered rehabilitation plan—not a means of silencing the horse sufficiently to keep it performing.
Interspinous Ligament Desmotomy: The “Ligament Snip”
Interspinous ligament desmotomy, or ISLD, involves surgically cutting the interspinous ligament between affected dorsal spinous processes.
It can be performed in the standing, sedated horse through relatively small incisions.
A controlled study involving 68 horses compared ISLD with corticosteroid treatment. Initial resolution of recognised back-pain signs occurred in both groups, but recurrence occurred in 19 medically treated horses and none of the surgical cases during the reported follow-up. Radiographs also demonstrated increased interspinous spacing following ISLD.[11]
Later research produced more nuanced results.
In one long-term study, 51 of 56 horses returned to some level of performance after ISLD, but only 27 returned to an equivalent or higher level than before surgery. Recurrent back pain accounted for some horses returning at a lower level.[12]
Advantages
ISLD is minimally invasive compared with traditional bone resection, can often be performed standing and has produced useful results in appropriately selected horses.
Limitations
It is still surgery.
Complications can occur, and cutting a ligament does not automatically correct the reason the horse developed dysfunctional spinal loading.
It also does not remove established bony pathology.
Postoperative rehabilitation remains essential.
Surgery creates an opportunity for the horse to move differently.
Rehabilitation teaches the horse what to do with that opportunity.
Bone Shave or Ostectomy
Where significant bony impingement exists, another surgical option is ostectomy.
Part of an affected dorsal spinous process is removed or reshaped so adjacent processes can no longer impinge in the same way.
This directly changes the anatomy rather than simply suppressing pain.
A case series of 23 horses undergoing subtotal ostectomy reported 19 returning to full athletic function within the first year.[13]
A larger study involving 102 horses treated using a minimally invasive technique reported complete resolution of recognised clinical signs and return to intended work in 80% of surviving horses available for long-term follow-up.
Horses without another orthopaedic problem had substantially better outcomes than horses with concurrent pathology.[14]
An older study involving 215 surgically treated horses reported 72% returning to full work, with another 9% returning to some athletic work.[15]
Advantages
Unlike pain-management approaches, ostectomy physically removes the area of bony impingement.
For advanced cases, this may be more logical than repeatedly suppressing pain from structures that continue to contact one another.
Limitations
It is more invasive than ISLD.
Recovery and rehabilitation are significant, and surgery does not guarantee restoration of normal movement or comfort. In fact, the body will eventually lay down more bone to stabilise the spine where the bone has been removed and over time, the horse may end up in a worse state than it started.
A horse that has spent years protecting its back has developed muscular and neurological compensation around that pain.
Removing part of a bone does not instantly teach the horse how to use its body normally again.
Nor does a published “return to work” statistic tell us everything we would want to know about each horse’s long-term comfort.
When Is Kissing Spine Too Far Gone?
There is no single X-ray at which every veterinarian can point and say:
“This horse can never be comfortable again.”
The number of affected processes matters.
The severity of remodelling matters.
Other spinal pathology matters.
Concurrent lameness matters.
Response to treatment matters.
And above all:
The horse’s quality of life matters.
There is an important distinction between being unsuitable for ridden work and being unable to enjoy a comfortable life.
A horse may no longer be an ethical candidate for carrying a rider while remaining perfectly capable of living happily as a paddock horse.
Where pain persists despite appropriate treatment, rehabilitation and management, however, the question eventually stops being:
“Can we get this horse back into work?”
and becomes:
“Can we keep this horse genuinely comfortable?”
That is a welfare decision, not a sporting one.
Can Kissing Spine Be Prevented?
We do not understand the causes well enough to promise prevention.
Genetic and developmental factors mean kissing spine cannot always be blamed on one rider, one saddle or one method of training.
But that does not mean management and training are irrelevant.
We can reduce avoidable stresses by:
ensuring appropriate saddle fit;
investigating lameness early;
developing the young horse progressively;
developing abdominal and postural strength;
strengthening and recruiting multifidus;
building the topline gradually;
avoiding prolonged hollow, braced movement;
providing sufficient recovery;
avoiding training through pain;
maintaining appropriate hoof balance;
recognising behavioural changes early; and
treating the horse’s body as an interconnected system.
Correct dressage should progressively improve the horse’s ability to support a rider.
It should not simply manufacture a particular neck position.
The hindquarters, pelvis, abdominal wall, thorax, back and neck all influence one another.
Healthy training should improve that system rather than merely produce the outward shape of a dressage horse.
The Dressage Atlas Position
This is where Dressage Atlas deliberately takes a conservative position.
There is disagreement within veterinary medicine about the significance of radiographic kissing-spine findings, particularly in horses without recognised clinical signs.
We acknowledge that uncertainty.
But uncertainty cuts both ways.
If science cannot establish that every horse with significant radiographic pathology is experiencing pain, neither can it establish that the quiet, compliant horse with the same pathology is pain-free simply because it continues to perform.
We therefore do not consider compliance sufficient evidence of comfort.
There is an important difference between slight narrowing without secondary change and established disease.
But where imaging demonstrates bone-on-bone contact accompanied by sclerosis, osteolysis, remodelling, overriding or other significant pathological change, Dressage Atlas does not believe the absence of dramatic behaviour should be used to justify continued ridden work.
This position is deliberately more conservative than some current approaches to kissing spine.
That is intentional.
Horses have different pain thresholds.
They express pain differently.
Some shout.
Some whisper.
And some continue doing exactly what we ask of them.
Just because the horse can does not necessarily mean the horse should.
When the uncertainty is whether sitting on a horse’s diseased spine hurts, we believe the horse deserves the benefit of that uncertainty.
References and Further Reading
Torcivia C, McDonnell S. In-Person Caretaker Visits Disrupt Ongoing Discomfort Behavior in Hospitalized Equine Orthopedic Surgical Patients. Animals. 2020;10(2):210. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10020210
Zimmerman M, Dyson S, Murray R. Close, impinging and overriding spinous processes in the thoracolumbar spine: the relationship between radiological and scintigraphic findings and clinical signs. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2012;44(2):178–184. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2042-3306.2011.00373.x
Haussler KK, Stover SM, Willits NH. Pathologic changes in the lumbosacral vertebrae and pelvis in Thoroughbred racehorses. American Journal of Veterinary Research. 1999;60(2):143–153. https://doi.org/10.2460/ajvr.1999.60.02.143
Infante D, Croxatto A, Corrêa F. Radiologic findings consistent with kissing spines syndrome in Chilean Thoroughbred horses. Sustainability, Agri, Food and Environmental Research. 2016;4(4):14–17.
Patterson Rosa L, Whitaker B, Allen K, et al. Genomic loci associated with performance-limiting equine overriding spinous processes (kissing spines). Research in Veterinary Science. 2022;150:65–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rvsc.2022.06.015
DeClue A. Kissing Spine in Sport Horses. The Horse First: A Veterinary Sport Horse Podcast. Episode 55, May 2023.
DeClue A. Kissing Spine in Sport Horses, Part Two: Do You Ride the Horse or the Radiograph? The Horse First: A Veterinary Sport Horse Podcast. Episode 56, September 2023.
Stubbs NC, Riggs CM, Hodges PW, Jeffcott LB, Hodgson DR, Clayton HM, McGowan CM. Osseous spinal pathology and epaxial muscle ultrasonography in Thoroughbred racehorses. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2010;42(Suppl 38):654–661. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2042-3306.2010.00258.x
Stubbs NC, Kaiser LJ, Hauptman J, Clayton HM. Dynamic mobilisation exercises increase cross-sectional area of musculus multifidus. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2011;43(5):522–529. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2042-3306.2010.00322.x
Coomer RPC, McKane SA, Smith N, Vandeweerd JME. A controlled study evaluating a novel surgical treatment for kissing spines in standing sedated horses. Veterinary Surgery. 2012;41(7):890–897. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1532-950X.2012.01013.x
Prisk AJ, García-López JM. Long-term prognosis for return to athletic function after interspinous ligament desmotomy for treatment of impinging and overriding dorsal spinous processes in horses: 71 cases (2012–2017). Veterinary Surgery. 2019.
Minimally invasive cranial ostectomy for the treatment of impinging dorsal spinous processes in 102 standing horses.Veterinary Surgery. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1111/vsu.13736
Walmsley JP, Pettersson H, Winberg F, McEvoy F. Impingement of the dorsal spinous processes in 215 horses: case selection, surgical technique and results. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2002;34(1):23–28.
I first learned about Hill Therapy many years ago through Linda Parelli’s Fluidity program. She taught me that knowing and understanding the posture, musculature and movement of horses is an important aspect of understanding dressage or even just general horse ownership.
Horses that have had a ridden career can often look very different from horses that have never been ridden. More often than not, it’s not for the better.
Unfortunately, this can lead to a horse breaking down in the long term, usually in the areas they over use to compensate for not sharing the load through the entire body such as the stifle, lower back, suspensory ligaments, hocks, and not to mention the knee, elbow and fetlock joints from landing heavily on the forehand.
Horse rehabilitation through Hill Therapy can completely transform a horse’s posture and movement.
How do horses get into this condition when ridden?
The reality is, a lot of this happens from ignorance. Ridden work too early on an undeveloped horse, inadequate preparation, poor saddle fit and poor riding all contribute to poor topline condition and development.
Horses that are started under saddle before the growth plates in their spine are closed are at significantly higher risk of damage to the skeleton and muscles that can lead to serious issues such as kissing spine or ankylosis. This leads to pain and weakness in the back, preventing the horse from being able to use their back properly to adequately build topline.
Horses that are left for long periods of time without being ridden and then the rider just drags them out of the paddock and jumps on to go for a 2 hour long trek are also at risk. Without adequate muscling and conditioning, the horse cannot use its muscles to lift through it’s thoracic sling, over it’s back and protect its skeletal frame.
Another big cause is the sad fact that many saddles are too restrictive for the horse.
A poor fitting saddle cannot do anything BUT inhibit the horses natural, flowing movement. Adding your weight to a poorly fitting saddle only compounds the issue.
I want to make it clear, trying to heal and repair your horses back without ensuring the saddle fits correctly is about as effective as poking yourself in the eye with a soldering iron to enable yourself to see better. It’s counterproductive to say the least.
The rider themselves could also be the cause. When the rider restricts a horse’s movement with a stiff, unfollowing seat, pulls on the reins constantly, lands heavily in the saddle or leans forward, putting their weight on the forehand; they will block the flow of energy through the whole horse much like a poor saddle does.
A ‘driving seat’ can literally push the horse’s back down with every stride.
The issues of saddle fit and poor riding alone are detrimental to the horse but the two combined are incredibly damaging to the horse.
Horse rehabilitation: Stop riding so the horse can heal
This is the hard part; some people are so fixated on riding that they have a lot of trouble coming to terms with the idea of staying off the horses back so he can heal. If the horse had blown a suspensory ligament, went lame or had an injury, not riding them is easy to understand because we understand that the horse needs rest in order to heal, but to do it when the horse is not limping or acting hurt is sometimes difficult to get our heads around. The reality is, you’ve got to see it coming and act on it now to prevent it.
Here’s some signs to look out for:
So, your horse is in bad shape
He’s a bit of a mess. He’s ticking too many of the above boxes. You need to do something about it.
Now, there are some pretty thorough and complex rehabilitation plans out there. Most of them require you to have a pretty decent skill set, an abundance of resources and obstacles, excessive amounts of time and the ability to get the horse to do things in juuuuuust the right way…or else.
I have something much easier to offer.
A simple yet incredibly effective treatment that takes about six Weeks: Hill Therapy
How to do Hill Therapy
1. You need to remove all the things that could be causing the horse to change his posture and way of moving, namely the saddle and the rider. No tack, other than a halter or lunge cavesson and lunge line or long (22ft) lead rope.
2. You need to let the horse move freely for a set amount of time in a certain way so that he can find his way to move more naturally again. In some cases the horse’s movement has been altered from the first day they ever carried a saddle and rider, and over the years they have actually habituated to it. A horse will completely change their natural way of moving even without a rider on them in order to protect their body. They need to re-learn how to use their whole body again.
3. Hills are the best medicine. You don’t want a steep hill, just an incline that encourages the horse to use himself more efficiently.
4. Send your horse out on a circle using a lunge line or 22-foot lead line. A standard length or 12-foot lead line is far too short; and a 45-foot lariat is too long!
This is not meant to be a perfect lunge lesson. This is rehabilitation.
Some notes about the hill:
a. A small incline, say 10 degrees, is ideal for trot and canter.
b. 15–20 degrees would only be suitable for walk and trot.
c. Anything steeper than that should only be at the walk.
Important Notes:
This is not meant to be physically stressful for the horse because you are trying to restore his health, not wear him out more!
If you don’t have hills, you can use barrels or barrel-sized logs (45cm/18 inches high) placed on the circle at three o’clock and nine o’clock.
Finally, the horse must be sound! Not limping or sore to move because he has an injury, arthritis or a bad back. Hill Therapy does not help an already broken-down horse, it restores one that is breaking down.
The Hill Therapy Program
Week 1: DAILY for 7 days
5 minutes circling.
2 minutes rest.
5 minutes circling in the other direction.
Week 2: Three times per week
5 minutes circling.
2 minutes rest.
5 minutes circling in the other direction.
Week 3–6: Twice per week
5 minutes circling.
2 minutes rest.
5 minutes circling in the other direction.
Note:
If the horse is fit, you may be able to double the times by Week 3. But if the horse is not very fit and the worse its condition, take it easy and go slower.
After following the six-week program, you shouldn’t need to do it anymore unless something causes the horse to deteriorate again. It makes sense that you would also need to check the fit and suitability of your saddle and address riding skills.
Use barrels or barrel sized logs if you don’t have hills.
What to expect
In just six weeks the transformation can be significant.
You’ll see the stride lengthen, back and neck muscles smooth out and develop, short necks lengthen, long backs shorten, strong under necks and dropped bellies tighten up, withers come up, high tail sets go down.
Many people cannot understand how horses can change their “conformation” so quickly. In reality, it’s not their conformation. It’s their posture. Conformation is all about the skeleton, the size and length and proportions of the bones. Posture is all about the soft tissue, muscle tone and development.
Muscles hold the skeleton in place and that’s why a horse can change shape.
You can test this theory for yourself. Stand with your shoulders rounded and belly sticking out, like that Orangutan…you know the one…like him. Now stand up straight, roll your shoulders back, engage your core and head up. Do you see how dramatically different you look just because you changed your posture? How do you tell a horse to stand up straight? How do you tell him to use his whole body when he moves? You can’t! So instead, you set it up so it occurs naturally. By asking your horse to keep moving, and setting it up to be a bit awkward because he has to take care of his balance going up and down hills, he finds a way to move much more efficiently. Part of the reason you have to do this for six weeks is because it has to become a new habit.
Troubleshooting
Your horse keeps changing gait while circling.
Don’t worry about it! That can be hard, I know but you need to remember that this is not conventional lunging. It’s a therapy. While your horse is trying to figure out how to move better, he’ll probably change gait a lot, in fact the worse shape he’s in the more likely he is to change gait.
Usually what you see is them slowing down on the way up the hill and speeding up on the way down because they ‘fall’ down the hill on their forehand and can’t push well enough and round their back on the way up.
Allow your horse to change gait, wait for half a lap and then ask him to take up the original gait again.
If you make him feel wrong for breaking gait, he’ll get emotionally upset and tense in his body, losing suppleness. You need him to be soft, confident and relaxed which will come with patience and understanding. Remember, he’s having trouble in his body so don’t force him through it.
Your horse keeps coming in to you.
Smile, give him a pat and politely send him on his way again. Don’t sacrifice the relationship over his body!
Your horse keeps trying to snatch grass as he goes around.
Well, at least he’s stretching his back! Allow him to grab a mouthful, count to three and ask him to move on again. Then each time allow less time; three seconds, two seconds, one second. Just don’t let it bother you or your horse will use it to rattle you!
Nothing seems to be happening!
At first your horse will probably have a lot of trouble making a circle. He’ll make oblongs in trying to shorten the up-hill and down-hill parts. He will probably have terrible posture, speed up and slow down, even look really uneven and almost lame as he hollows out and stiff-legs it on the downhill run. He may even stop dead before going down the hill or bend his body all wrong or not want to go in one direction at all. Just so you know, that’s pretty normal in the beginning. Your horse is experimenting and pretty soon the changes will come. Try not to correct everything, just observe and understand why. It seems to be by the fourth day that the biggest change can be observed and right up until then you could see little or no improvement at all! But then the prize comes; the neck stretches down, the back starts to round up, the strides get softer, longer, springy; then his balance improves, he’s not on the forehand anymore, he doesn’t change speed or rhythm on any part of the circle and you start to notice subtle changes in his muscling like overdeveloped areas getting smaller and underdeveloped areas building up. It’s very exciting.
Is it better to trot or canter rather than walk?
Not necessarily because you can change the incline of the slope you use to cause the horse to use himself more efficiently. It’s not about working up a sweat or tiring out your horse. You can think about asking for the canter towards the end of the program around Week 4 to help develop your horse’s balance at that gait.
Why wouldn’t you keep doing it?
Because it shouldn’t be necessary. Once you’ve brought the horse back to health physically, you maintain it with ground skills and good riding and saddles. This is remedial therapy so once the horse is healed you shouldn’t have to keep doing it.
In what situations would you NOT do Hill Therapy?
If your horse was…
Too green, meaning uneducated.
Hill therapy needs to be done in a controlled manner. A young, uneducated horse zooming up and down hills could potentially lead to slips, trips and falls that may cause serious injury. Over time, horses come to understand that there’s something to this. They feel the benefits, get to know the routine and can actually seem to enjoy it.
Lameness.
If your horse is showing any sign of lameness, this is not the right thing to be doing for him. You should seek veterinary advice.
Too old.
I would probably not do this with a horse that was older than 17 unless it was in good health. Even, then I would probably only do it at the walk on a slightly steeper incline. You have to be mindful that wear and tear on old joints is not what you want.
Lordosis or a sway back
I would use walking cavalettis/poles instead and over a much longer period of time. Where exercise is indicated but needs to be minimal physical stress/impact, walking over a cavaletti can be a good substitute. It helps horses to stretch their backs and use their top line but is not as efficient in getting horses to dramatically change the way they move.
Locking stifles.
Check with your vet first. Locking stifles are often caused by a lack of sufficient musculature around the stifle to keep the patella in the groove that it is supposed to slide up and down in. I have personally seen some very good changes in locking stifle problems through Hill Therapy but you need to be careful. It would be best at the walk, over a longer period of time and build up slowly.
Whether your horse has had six weeks off, six months off, or is returning from injury, there is one very tempting mistake:
Climb back on and carry on where you left off.
Don’t do that.
Bringing a horse can into work is a careful task. The horse remembers the work. They may feel fresh, enthusiastic and perfectly capable of doing it. They might trot around happily for 40 minutes on their first day back.
That doesn’t mean their body is ready for it.
Bringing a horse back into work isn’t simply about getting them puffing less. Cardiovascular fitness is only one piece of the puzzle. Muscles, tendons, ligaments, joints, bone and the postural system all need time and appropriate loading to adapt again.
The goal isn’t to see how quickly we can get the horse working.
It’s to progressively prepare the horse’s body for the work we eventually want it to do.
What Happens During Time Off?
The body adapts to the demands placed upon it.
When regular exercise stops, those demands disappear and the body gradually adapts in the opposite direction.
How much conditioning is lost depends on how long the horse has been out of work, what they were doing beforehand, their age, turnout and general activity, and whether the break involved injury or confinement.
A horse living outside and walking kilometres around a paddock is in a very different starting position from a horse that has spent several weeks on box rest.
But neither should automatically return to their previous workload on day one.
Cardiovascular fitness
The heart and lungs lose some of their conditioning during extended periods without exercise.
Interestingly, cardiovascular fitness can also return relatively quickly.
That’s useful for us and the horse but it can be deceptive.
A horse may stop puffing and begin to feel fit long before some of the slower-adapting structures of the body are prepared for harder work.
Muscle
Muscle strength and endurance decrease when they aren’t being regularly challenged.
For the dressage horse, it’s not just about the obvious muscles that propel the horse forward.
There are also muscles that are responsible for posture, balance and stabilisation that also need rebuilding.
That especially includes the muscles that are supporting the back, abdominal chain, pelvis and joints.
Tendons and ligaments
Tendons and ligaments adapt to repeated mechanical loading.
They need that loading but they need it progressively.
Suddenly returning a previously conditioned horse to its old workload can expose structures that are no longer conditioned for the forces being placed upon them.
Bone
Bone isn’t an inert framework either.
It continually responds and remodels according to the stresses placed upon it. Appropriate weight-bearing exercise encourages that adaptation. This is known as Wolff’s Law.
Again, the key word here is appropriate.
More work isn’t automatically better. Progressive loading gives the body the opportunity to adapt.
The Brain Remembers Faster Than the Body Rebuilds
This is one of the biggest traps with experienced horses.
They haven’t forgotten how to canter.
They haven’t forgotten lateral work.
They haven’t forgotten how to collect.
An experienced horse returning from a break may happily offer movements that its current physical conditioning isn’t ready to sustain.
Skill and physical preparedness are not the same thing.
Just because a horse can perform something doesn’t necessarily mean it should be performing it yet.
This is particularly important with movements involving greater force loading, impact, collection, impulsion, lateral loading or repeated transitions.
Bringing a Horse back into Work after Injury Is Different
If the horse has been out of work because of injury, the rehabilitation programme should be based on the structure injured, severity of the injury, healing stage and veterinary assessment.
A generic “six-week fitness programme” cannot account for that.
Some injuries require controlled straight-line walking. Others may require restrictions on circles, uneven surfaces, speed or duration. The appropriate progression for one injury may be completely inappropriate for another.
When returning from injury, veterinary rehabilitation instructions take priority over any general conditioning advice.
Once the horse has been cleared to progressively return to normal exercise, however, the same underlying principle remains:
Load → recover → adapt → gradually increase the load.
Start With Walking
Walking isn’t the boring bit before the real work starts.
Walking is work.
A purposeful walk allows the horse to begin rebuilding conditioning while keeping forces relatively low. Purposeful being the objective word here.
Depending on the horse’s starting point, early sessions might consist almost entirely of walking.
Start with a duration the horse can comfortably manage and build from there.
For some horses that might initially be 5-10 minutes in each direction on the lunge or hand walking; gradually increasing to 20–30 minutes.
The correct starting point depends on how long the horse has been off, what they have been doing during that time and why they stopped working in the first place.
You Don’t Have to Start Under Saddle
Returning to work doesn’t necessarily mean returning to riding immediately. And you shouldn’t.
There are plenty of ways to begin rebuilding the horse before adding the weight and balance demands of a rider, especially when trying to protect a spine with weakened back muscles.
In-hand walking
Probably the simplest place to begin.
Forward, purposeful walking can start rebuilding general conditioning while allowing you to observe how the horse moves.
Over time you can introduce changes of direction, poles and varied terrain where appropriate.
Groundwork
Good groundwork can help re-establish responsiveness, body awareness and basic movement patterns before ridden work resumes.
Keep the emphasis on quality rather than making the exercises complicated.
Pole work
Walk poles can encourage the horse to organise its feet, increase joint flexion and use its body differently without requiring speed.
Introduce them progressively rather than immediately creating elaborate pole grids.
Long-reining
For horses already educated to long-reining, it can be an excellent bridge between basic groundwork and ridden exercise.
It allows purposeful forward movement without the rider’s weight while beginning to reintroduce more structured work.
Lunging
Lunging can be useful, but it deserves some caution.
Working continuously on a circle creates different loading from travelling in straight lines. Small circles and prolonged lunging aren’t necessarily appropriate for an unconditioned horse and could even be specifically unsuitable during rehabilitation from certain injuries.
If lunging is used, begin with large circles, short periods and plenty of changes of direction.
It shouldn’t become “20 minutes of trotting around in circles because we’re getting him fit.”
Frequency Beats Heroic Sessions
One enormous workout followed by several days doing nothing isn’t particularly useful for progressive conditioning.
Regular, manageable sessions are generally more productive.
For a sound horse returning after ordinary time off, 3–5 appropriately sized sessions each week may be more useful than one or two big workouts.
That doesn’t mean five hard training sessions.
Early in the programme, a “session” might simply be:
20 minutes purposeful in-hand walking
a short groundwork session followed by walking
a ridden walk
a gentle pole session
walking over suitable varied terrain
The workload can gradually increase as the horse adapts.
Recovery days are part of conditioning too.
Increase One Thing at a Time
There are several ways to make exercise harder:
Duration: working for longer.
Frequency: working more often.
Intensity: progressively asking for more demanding work.
Complexity: progressively adding transitions, poles, lateral work or more difficult exercises.
Terrain: introducing slopes and different surfaces over time.
The mistake is increasing everything simultaneously when you should be changing the workload gradually.
For example, first build the duration of walking. Then introduce short periods of trot. Gradually increase the amount of trot before introducing significant canter work or more demanding schooling.
There doesn’t need to be a rigid universal timetable.
The horse should determine the rate of progression.
What About Trotting and Cantering?
Once the horse is comfortably coping with its walking workload, trot can be introduced in short intervals.
Think:
Walk → short trot → walk → recover → repeat.
As conditioning improves, those trot intervals can gradually become longer.
Canter follows the same principle.
Don’t introduce it simply because the horse feels fresh enough to canter.
Introduce it when the horse has developed sufficient conditioning, balance and strength to perform it without fatigue significantly compromising the quality of movement.
Fatigue Changes Movement
This is one of the biggest reasons not to push a horse through a return-to-work programme too quickly.
A tired horse doesn’t simply become slower.
As muscles fatigue, the horse’s ability to stabilise its body and maintain good movement can deteriorate.
You may notice:
rhythm deteriorating
stumbling or toe dragging
shortening of the stride
increasing crookedness
difficulty maintaining balance
reluctance to go forward
transitions becoming progressively worse
the horse leaning increasingly on the rider
loss of coordination
At that point, doing another twenty minutes isn’t “building fitness.”
The quality of the work has already deteriorated. Now you’re training sub standard quality work.
Conditioning should create adaptation, not exhaustion.
Don’t Forget the Training Scale
Returning to work isn’t the time to immediately chase collection.
Go back to the foundations.
Rhythm comes first: can the horse maintain a regular tempo without fatigue?
Suppleness develops as the body begins moving freely again.
Connection can be progressively re-established once the horse is confidently travelling forward.
Impulsion requires sufficient strength and conditioning to produce energy without rushing.
Straightness becomes increasingly important as the workload grows.
And collection belongs later, once the horse has developed the strength to carry more weight behind.
The Training Scale isn’t something we abandon while getting a horse fit.
It helps tell us whether the horse is ready for the next step.
Watch the Horse Between Sessions
Don’t judge the programme solely by what happens during the workout.
Look at the horse later that day and the following day.
Are they moving freely?
Are they unusually stiff?
Is there heat or swelling?
Have they become reluctant to move forward?
Has their behaviour changed when being caught, saddled or asked to exercise?
The response after exercise tells you whether the previous workload was appropriate.
If the horse isn’t recovering comfortably, increasing the workload isn’t progression.
There Is No Universal Six-Week Programme
A timetable can be useful as a guide, but horses don’t read calendars.
A young horse returning after eight weeks living in a large paddock is not equivalent to an older horse returning after months of restricted movement.
Neither is equivalent to a horse returning from tendon rehabilitation.
Progress according to the horse in front of you.
Instead of asking:
“What should we be doing in Week 4?”
Ask:
“Is this horse physically ready for the next increase in workload?”
That’s a far more useful question.
Build the Horse You Want to Train
It can feel painfully slow when you’re desperate to get back to schooling.
But those early weeks aren’t wasted time.
They’re where you’re rebuilding the physical foundation that everything else depends upon.
Walking, groundwork, poles, gradual trot work and progressive strengthening aren’t obstacles standing between you and dressage.
They’re part of training the dressage horse.
Once the basic conditioning has returned, we can begin using the environment itself to develop strength, balance and coordination.
We categorise training methods, argue about which philosophy an exercise belongs to and occasionally behave as though crossing from one discipline into another requires a passport.
My first dressage horse, in a western saddle and bitless rope halter.
Your horse, meanwhile, has absolutely no idea.
They don’t know they’re a dressage horse. They don’t know that yielding their hindquarters might be considered natural horsemanship, that trotting over poles supposedly belongs to another discipline, or that backing up appears in one training system under a completely different name from another.
The horse only knows what we are asking, whether they understand the question, and what happens when they find the right answer.
That opens up an enormous toolbox for the dressage rider.
The Goal Matters More Than the Label
Dressage requires a huge range of physical and mental qualities from the horse.
We want rhythm, suppleness, connection, impulsion, straightness and eventually collection. But underneath those familiar Training Scale terms are more fundamental abilities.
The horse needs to understand pressure and release. They need proprioception, control and awareness of their own body. They need to be able to move the shoulders and hindquarters independently, regulate their footfalls, respond to subtle cues, remain confident when presented with something unfamiliar and maintain attention without becoming dependent on constant direction from the rider.
These things are understood best by the horse when they are first presented from the ground.
And they certainly don’t have to be taught inside a 20 × 60 metre sandpit.
Moving the Hindquarters
Can you ask your horse from the ground to move their hindquarters away from a light cue?
At first glance, it looks like a basic groundwork exercise with little relevance to dressage.
However, consider what the horse is actually learning.
They are learning that a cue directed towards one area of their body means move that part of your body away from the pressure.
Later, from the saddle, we expect the horse to understand that the rider’s leg can influence the hindquarters without simply meaning go faster. This is easier for the horse to understand when they have first grasped the concept from the ground.
The finished dressage movement such as Travers may look completely different, but part of the horse’s understanding has already begun by simply learning to move their hindquarters.
Moving the Shoulders
The same applies to the shoulders.
Being able to influence the shoulders independently is fundamental to straightness, accurate turns and eventually lateral work such as shoulder-in.
Teaching this from the ground gives the horse an opportunity to understand the basic concept without also having to balance a rider, maintain a particular outline and interpret several aids simultaneously.
Breaking a complicated question into smaller pieces makes the learning processes easier, more enjoyable and more relaxed.
That’s not a natural horsemanship idea or a dressage idea.
It’s just good teaching.
Backing Up
Backing is another exercise that appears across virtually every school of horsemanship.
Done thoughtfully, it asks the horse to coordinate their limbs in an unfamiliar direction, respond to a relatively subtle request and organise their body without simply travelling forward.
It can also begin to introduce the idea that an aid doesn’t always mean more forward which can often be a horses go-to.
Later, rein-back becomes a formal dressage movement.
The horse doesn’t know that.
To them, it’s simply another movement they have learned to perform from a particular set of cues.
Poles, Obstacles and Uneven Questions
Dressage arenas are deliberately predictable.
That’s useful for competition, but it doesn’t mean all training should be. Variety is the spice of life.
Poles, obstacles and varied exercises ask horses to think about where they’re putting their feet.
A horse stepping through poles has to organise their stride, think about where they’re putting their feet, how to balance themselves through the obstacles and negotiate the question in front of them.
Those skills can contribute to proprioception, coordination, confidence and body awareness. All of which are necessary for dressage.
You don’t get extra marks in a dressage test because your horse can walk over a tarpaulin.
Nevertheless, a horse that has learned to calmly assess unfamiliar questions and work out where its feet are may bring something valuable back into the arena.
Lunging Over a Small Jump
This is one of my favourite examples because, on paper, jumping has very little to do with dressage.
We’re not trying to turn the dressage horse into a showjumper.
A small, appropriately set obstacle on the lunge presents the horse with a physical problem they have to solve without a rider organising every stride for them.
They need to approach in rhythm, judge where their feet need to go, coordinate their body over the obstacle, balance for the take off and regain their balance on landing.
The jump is simply the tool.
The lesson is body awareness, coordination and self-organisation.
Leading Is Training Too
Even ordinary tasks such as leading can be useful training when we pay attention to what we’re teaching.
Can the horse walk when you walk?
Stop when you stop?
Increase or decrease the pace without barging ahead or falling behind?
Change direction while remaining attentive to your body language?
Stand quietly until asked to move?
These aren’t spectacular exercises. Nobody is going to gather around the arena fence to applaud your beautifully executed walk from the gate.
Responsiveness to small cues and being in tune with the rider is something we’re going to ask for repeatedly in dressage.
The communication starts long before we climb into the saddle.
Don’t Collect Exercises; Understand Them
There is a trap here.
Looking outside of dressage doesn’t mean grabbing every interesting groundwork exercise you see and assuming it must be beneficial.
Before adding an exercise to your training, ask:
What am I trying to teach?
What does this exercise actually ask the horse to do?
What physical or mental quality could it develop?
Does my horse understand the question?
Will this help us towards the training goal we’re working on?
If you can’t answer those questions, the exercise may simply be something to do.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with that. Horses are allowed to do things purely because they’re enjoyable.
Training with purpose means understanding what you’re asking and why you’re asking for it.
Good Horsemanship Doesn’t Belong to a Discipline
There is plenty we can learn from dressage masters.
There is also plenty we can learn from showjumpers, eventers, western riders, natural horsemanship trainers, racing people, working-equitation riders, equine physiotherapists and the person down the road who has quietly handled hundreds of horses for forty years.
We don’t have to adopt somebody’s entire training philosophy to recognise when they have a useful idea.
Take the exercise apart.
Look at what it teaches.
Keep what helps the horse.
Leave what doesn’t.
Because while humans may spend hours deciding whether something is really dressage, the horse isn’t remotely interested in the argument.
What natural horsemanship can teach us about training the dressage horse.
If you walk into a dressage arena carrying a rope halter and a stick with a piece of string attached to it and you might get some interesting looks.
Start waving the string around and things may deteriorate further.
But beneath the cowboy hats, rope halters, carrot sticks and occasionally enthusiastic quantities of wavy flappy things is something dressage riders should probably be paying attention to:
Horsemanship.
Because when you strip away the branding, terminology and equipment, much of what natural horsemanship teaches is remarkably familiar.
Control the feet. Influence the shoulders. Influence the hindquarters. Move toward pressure. Move away from pressure. Follow a feel. Maintain rhythm and direction. Develop confidence. Respond to increasingly subtle aids.
Sound familiar?
It should.
Because eventually we put a saddle on, ride down the centreline and call many of those same skills dressage.
What Actually Is “Natural Horsemanship”?
Pat Parelli unquestionably became one of the biggest forces in popularising and systematising natural horsemanship, particularly through the Parelli programme and Seven Games. But the underlying ideas predate Parelli by a very long way.
Long before Parelli, horsemen including Ray Hunt and Tom and Bill Dorrance were helping shape and spread the style of American horsemanship we recognise today. Ronnie Willis was another important influence on Parelli himself.
But cowboys didn’t invent horsemanship either.
Long before Hunt, the Dorrances, Willis or Parelli, Spanish and Mexican vaqueros were developing sophisticated systems of horsemanship in the American West. Their horses needed to be light, responsive and manoeuvrable, capable of being ridden with increasingly subtle aids while doing very practical work. Many of the principles we now associate with good Western or “natural” horsemanship have much older roots.
Vaqueros Lassoing Steer Artist: Augusto Ferran (1813–1879) c. 1849
Here’s where things get interesting for dressage riders.
The vaquero tradition grew from Spanish horsemanship, which shared roots and influences with the wider European equestrian traditions from which classical dressage developed. They aren’t the same system, nor is there a neat historical line connecting one directly to the other, but it’s not at all surprising that we find familiar ideas on both sides: lightness, balance, responsiveness, control of the shoulders and hindquarters, progressive training and, ultimately, doing more with less.
Tom and Bill Dorrance, Ray Hunt and later horsemen helped shape and spread these principles through modern American horsemanship, while Parelli packaged many of them into a system that became accessible to ordinary horse owners around the world.
Different clothes. Different equipment. Different terminology.
But underneath it all sits a remarkably familiar idea:
Understand the horse, teach them one piece at a time, and progressively develop those simple responses into something much more sophisticated.
Natural horsemanship isn’t really new.
Neither is dressage.
They’re modern labels attached to principles horsemen have been discovering, refining and arguing about for centuries.
Good horsemanship is good horsemanship.
A horse doesn’t know whether an exercise came from a cowboy, a classical riding master, a behavioural scientist or somebody wearing white breeches.
Does it help the horse understand what we’re asking?
The Parelli Seven Games Through Dressage Eyes
1. The Friendly Game
You can trust what happens around you.
The horse learns to tolerate and eventually relax around touch, equipment, movement and environmental stimuli. Not learned helplessness but genuine confidence. The horse can manage their emotions and knows what to do with what’s presented.
Dressage connections: Accepting the whip touching the body, girthing, mounting, leg contact, rein movement, jackets moving, arena decorations, judges’ boxes and generally remaining relaxed while the rider does weird human things above them.
Before we can influence a horse, the horse needs to be comfortable enough to receive information without reacting defensively to it.
2. The Porcupine Game
Move away from steady pressure.
This one is dressage everywhere.
Pressure against the ribcage → move sideways.
Pressure near the hindquarters → move the quarters.
Rein pressure → respond appropriately to the rein.
Dressage connections: Leg-yield, turn on the forehand, turn on the haunches, shoulder-in, travers, renvers, half-pass and eventually increasingly sophisticated lateral positioning.
The dressage rider calls them aids.
The horse experiences pressure and release.
3. The Driving Game
Respond to rhythmic pressure without physical contact.
Now we’re getting really interesting.
The horse learns that an energetic or spatial cue can influence movement before physical pressure becomes necessary.
Dressage connections: The whip used as a secondary aid, directing the shoulders or quarters, transitions, groundwork, in-hand work and eventually the horse responding to incredibly subtle changes in the rider’s body and intent.
The ultimate dressage horse isn’t responding because we’re physically pushing its body into position.
It’s responding to signals predicting what we want it to do.
4. The Yo-Yo Game
Move away and come back.
On the ground: forwards and backwards while maintaining attention, straightness and responsiveness.
At the highest levels, even the ability to bring the horse’s forward energy progressively back toward piaffe relies on the same fundamental concept: the horse must remain responsive as we ask for more forward or less forward without losing organisation.
Dressage continually asks the horse to shift its balance while remaining attentive and responsive.
Eventually we give that ability a very dressage-y word:
Adjustability.
5. The Circling Game
Maintain gait, rhythm and direction.
Well, this one’s hardly difficult to connect.
Dressage connections: Circles, lunging, rhythm, tempo, bend, transitions on a circle and eventually developing balance without the rider micromanaging every stride.
The important principle isn’t simply horse goes around human.
It’s:
Can I establish a task and have the horse maintain it without constantly nagging?
That’s enormously relevant to dressage.
A horse that only maintains trot because the rider kicks every second stride hasn’t really learned to maintain trot.
6. The Sideways Game
Move laterally.
Hello, dressage.
Dressage connections: Leg-yield, shoulder-in, travers, renvers and half-pass.
The sophistication changes enormously.
The fundamental concept doesn’t:
Can you influence the horse’s body laterally?
The groundwork version might be crude compared with a balanced half-pass in collected trot, but it introduces the horse to the basic concept upon which that later movement depends.
7. The Squeeze Game
Move confidently through, between, over or under things.
This is probably the one people will initially think has the least relevance to dressage.
Until you think about what it actually develops.
Confidence. Straightness. Commitment to a line. Following direction despite uncertainty.
Dressage connections: Riding between the aids, straightness, narrow corridors, poles, cavaletti, entering unfamiliar arenas, passing judges’ boxes, moving toward something the horse would rather avoid and learning that the rider can provide direction without forcing the horse through panic.
It’s not teaching half-pass.
It’s teaching something potentially more fundamental:
When I give you a direction, can you confidently follow it?
Different Languages. Same Horse.
A cowboy might talk about moving the feet.
A dressage trainer might talk about influencing the quarters.
A classical trainer might talk about mobilising the haunches.
An equitation scientist might describe a learned response to an operant cue.
And the horse is standing there thinking:
You want my bum over there.
Terminology is useful, particularly as training becomes more sophisticated, but terminology can also disguise how simple the foundations actually are.
Sometimes we’re arguing over language while asking the horse essentially the same question.
Where Natural Horsemanship and Dressage Collide
Natural horsemanship isn’t dressage.
Teaching a horse to yield its quarters doesn’t mean you’ve taught travers.
Moving sideways isn’t automatically leg-yield.
Backing up isn’t collection.
Circling isn’t necessarily correct bend.
Dressage takes these fundamental responses and progressively adds biomechanical requirements:
Which brings us to perhaps the simplest way of looking at the relationship between the two.
Natural Horsemanship Is the Cake. Dressage Is the Icing.
You can’t ice something that doesn’t exist.
Before we worry about whether the horse’s shoulder-in has precisely the correct angle, we need a horse that understands:
Go. Stop. Come back. Move over. Move your shoulders. Move your quarters. Follow this direction. Maintain what I’ve asked for. Accept pressure. Respond to pressure. Relax when the pressure disappears. Trust me when you’re uncertain.
That’s the cake.
Dressage takes those responses and refines them. We add balance, posture, precision and progressively greater control of the horse’s body. The aids become smaller. The questions become more complicated. The answers become more sophisticated.
That’s the icing.
And no amount of beautiful icing can compensate for a cake that wasn’t properly made underneath.
In Conclusion
Dressage doesn’t need to become natural horsemanship.
Natural horsemanship doesn’t need to become dressage.
And nobody needs to swap their double bridle for a rope halter and start waving a carrot stick around at Prix St Georges.
But dressage riders can learn from good horsemen wherever they find them.
The greatest mistake is believing that because somebody uses different equipment, different terminology or comes from a different training tradition, they have nothing relevant to teach us.
The horse doesn’t care what we call it.
Good training progressively expands the horse’s vocabulary until increasingly complicated questions can be answered with increasingly subtle conversations.
And that, really, is what dressage is supposed to be.
Modern dressage is the training system most riders encounter today through national federations, professional trainers and international competition. While rooted in classical principles developed over centuries, modern dressage has evolved alongside advances in sports science, biomechanics and the increasing demands of high-level competition.
The goal remains the same as it always has been: to develop a horse that is balanced, supple, obedient, athletic and enjoyable to ride. However, modern training often places greater emphasis on measurable progression, competition performance and systematic development through the dressage levels.
History of Modern Dressage
Modern dressage is derived primarily from the German classical system, which itself traces back to the teachings of Xenophon, La Guérinière, Steinbrecht and other influential masters.
During the twentieth century, national training systems became increasingly standardised. The German Training Scale became widely adopted around the world and now forms the foundation of many national coaching programmes.
Modern dressage has also incorporated research into equine biomechanics, veterinary medicine, sports psychology and rider performance.
Core Philosophy
Modern dressage seeks to produce a horse that is:
Relaxed
Responsive
Straight
Balanced
Powerful
Capable of performing increasingly difficult movements without tension.
Training generally follows a progressive pathway where each level prepares the horse for the next.
The emphasis is on systematic development rather than isolated tricks or movements.
Key Training Principles
Modern training typically emphasises:
The Training Scale
Correct basics before advanced work
Straightness before collection
Progressive conditioning
Gymnastic development
Rider effectiveness
Consistency and repetition
Measurable improvement
Exercises are selected because they improve specific qualities rather than simply teaching movements.
Typical Characteristics
Modern dressage training often includes:
Frequent transitions
Circles and serpentines
Lateral work
Pole work
Progressive strengthening
Competition-focused preparation
Regular assessment against judging standards
Training sessions generally contain a combination of suppling work, strengthening exercises and technical practice.
Strengths
Modern dressage offers several advantages:
Highly structured progression.
Well-developed coaching systems.
Widely available educational resources.
Strong biomechanical understanding.
Clear competition pathway.
Exercises designed to systematically improve the horse.
For many riders, this provides an accessible roadmap from beginner through to Grand Prix.
Limitations
Modern dressage is sometimes criticised for:
Becoming overly competition-focused.
Chasing scores rather than correct training.
Rushing progression.
Excessive repetition.
Over-flexion or forced outlines when incorrectly applied.
Losing individual consideration for each horse.
Importantly, these issues are generally the result of poor training rather than flaws in the underlying principles.
Suitable Horses and Riders
Modern dressage suits riders who enjoy:
Structured learning.
Goal setting.
Competition.
Progressive skill development.
Objective feedback.
It can be adapted for almost any breed when the training remains sympathetic to the individual horse.
Common Misconceptions
Modern dressage is often misunderstood.
It is not simply “head set” training.
It is not about forcing collection.
It is not intended to prioritise appearance over correctness.
Well-executed modern dressage should produce a horse that is relaxed, willing, through and athletic.
How It Relates to Dressage Atlas
Dressage Atlas primarily follows the modern systematic approach because it provides a logical framework for organising exercises, movements and progression.
However, many exercises and concepts throughout the website also originate from earlier classical traditions. The philosophies of these classical traditions can be applied to any and all of the Dressage Atlas program.
Summary
Modern dressage combines centuries of classical knowledge with contemporary coaching methods and biomechanics. When applied correctly, it develops horses progressively through careful gymnastic training while maintaining the welfare, confidence and athletic ability of the horse.
Equitation Science is a modern, evidence-based approach to horse training that applies the principles of learning theory, behavioural science and biomechanics to improve communication between horse and rider. Rather than being rooted in centuries of tradition, Equitation Science draws on scientific research to better understand how horses learn, respond to pressure and process information.
Its primary goal is to train horses in a way that is effective, ethical and minimises confusion, stress and conflict.
History of Equitation Science
Equitation Science emerged in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries as researchers began studying equine behaviour and learning in greater depth.
Much of its development has been led by the International Society for Equitation Science (ISES), with researchers such as Andrew McLean, Paul McGreevy and others publishing work on learning theory, horse welfare and rider communication.
Today, Equitation Science influences coaching, veterinary science, horse welfare organisations and competitive disciplines around the world.
Core Philosophy
Equitation Science is built around a simple principle:
Train the horse according to how horses learn, rather than how humans think they should learn.
Instead of relying primarily on tradition or intuition, training decisions are guided by scientific understanding of:
Learning theory
Equine cognition
Behaviour
Stress physiology
Biomechanics
Welfare
The emphasis is on clarity, consistency and fairness.
Key Training Principles
Equitation Science commonly emphasises:
Pressure and timely release
Negative reinforcement used correctly
Positive reinforcement where appropriate
Habituation
Shaping behaviours gradually
One response per aid
Consistent signals
Avoiding conflicting aids
Minimising stress and confusion
Training is designed so the horse clearly understands the desired response.
Typical Characteristics
Training sessions often include:
Breaking complex behaviours into smaller steps.
Careful timing of rewards and pressure release.
Consistent rider aids.
Observation of behavioural signs of stress.
Progressive development.
Frequent reinforcement of correct responses.
Focus on rider skill and timing.
Exercises may look very similar to traditional dressage, but greater emphasis is placed on how the horse learns the exercise.
Strengths
Equitation Science offers several advantages:
Strong scientific foundation.
Clear understanding of learning processes.
Improved welfare outcomes.
Reduced confusion for the horse.
Applicable across all riding disciplines.
Encourages riders to become more consistent and effective communicators.
Its principles can complement many existing training systems.
Limitations
Some criticisms include:
It may appear overly technical or academic.
It focuses primarily on learning processes rather than artistic tradition.
Some riders feel it lacks the historical or philosophical depth of classical schools.
Scientific understanding continues to evolve, meaning recommendations may change as new research emerges.
Like any system, successful application depends on the skill of the trainer.
Suitable Horses and Riders
Equitation Science is well suited to:
Riders who enjoy understanding why training works.
Coaches seeking evidence-based methods.
Riders interested in horse welfare.
Owners training young or inexperienced horses.
Anyone wanting clearer communication with their horse.
Its principles can be incorporated into almost any riding discipline.
Common Misconceptions
Equitation Science is sometimes misunderstood as being “anti-classical” or “anti-tradition.”
In reality, it does not prescribe a particular riding style or discipline. Instead, it provides a scientific framework for understanding how horses learn, allowing riders to apply those principles within their chosen training philosophy.
How It Relates to Dressage Atlas
Dressage Atlas is primarily organised around modern and classical dressage systems. However, many of the training methods described throughout the website can be enhanced by applying the principles of Equitation Science.
Understanding how horses learn helps riders use exercises more effectively, regardless of the training philosophy they follow.
Summary
Equitation Science combines behavioural science, learning theory and equine welfare to create a modern framework for horse training. Rather than replacing classical dressage, it offers valuable insights into how horses learn, helping riders communicate more clearly and train more effectively.
The German classical dressage system is arguably the most influential dressage training philosophy in the world. It forms the basis of many national coaching systems and gave rise to the modern Training Scale used internationally.
Its defining feature is systematic gymnastic development, where each stage of training prepares the horse physically and mentally for the next.
English: Kingdom of Hannover Regiment of Garde du Corps (Troops) Deutsch: Garde du Corps Mannschaften (Hannover) circa 1835-1843
Historyof German Classical Dressage
The German system evolved from the writings of:
Xenophon
François Robichon de La Guérinière
Gustav Steinbrecht
Felix Bürkner
Steinbrecht’s famous statement,
“Ride your horse forward and make him straight,”
remains one of the defining principles of German training.
The German National Equestrian Federation later formalised these ideas into today’s Training Scale.
Core Philosophy
German training aims to produce a horse that is:
Straight
Balanced
Elastic
Powerful
Through
Self-carrying
The horse develops strength gradually through carefully selected gymnastic exercises.
Collection is viewed as the result of correct training rather than an end in itself.
Key Training Principles
German classical training centres on:
Rhythm
Relaxation
Contact
Impulsion
Straightness
Collection
These qualities build progressively and continuously throughout the horse’s career.
Exercises are selected according to what quality they improve.
Typical Characteristics
Training commonly includes:
Large amounts of transitions.
Circles.
Lateral work.
Straightness exercises.
Pole work.
Progressive collection.
Frequent use of shoulder-in.
Every exercise has a gymnastic purpose.
Strengths
The German system provides:
Clear progression.
Excellent physical development.
Strong focus on balance.
Highly repeatable methods.
Excellent preparation for competition.
Adaptability across many horses.
It remains one of the most thoroughly documented systems in the world.
Limitations
Potential criticisms include:
Can become a bit dogmatic and repetitive in its patterns, rules or formulas..
Riders sometimes become overly reliant on the Training Scale without considering the individual horse.
Competition can encourage shortcuts.
Some trainers focus excessively on mechanics rather than feel.
These are generally issues of application rather than philosophy and can be circumnavigated by the thoughtful rider.
Suitable Horses and Riders
The German approach suits riders who enjoy:
Structure.
Logical progression.
Measurable improvement.
Technical accuracy.
Common Misconceptions
German dressage is sometimes portrayed as rigid or mechanical.
In reality, classical German masters consistently emphasised patience, feel, lightness and harmony.
The horse’s welfare was intended to remain central to the training.
How It Relates to Dressage Atlas
Dressage Atlas is set up around the systematic nature of German training.
The organisation of the Training Scale, levels, movements and exercises reflects this logical progression.
That is not to say that we think this is the ‘right’ way or the ‘only’ way but instead we are utilising the methodical nature of German training to present Dressage Atlas.
Summary
German classical dressage offers one of the clearest and most comprehensive systems for developing a horse from basic education through to the highest levels. Its emphasis on gymnastic development continues to influence dressage around the world.
Portuguese Classical Dressage is a traditional system of horse training that places great emphasis on balance, collection, lightness and harmony between horse and rider. Developed alongside Portugal’s long tradition of working horses and bullfighting horses, it seeks to produce a horse that is agile, responsive and capable of performing advanced movements with ease.
Although influenced by many of the same historical masters as French Classical dressage, Portuguese riding has developed its own distinct identity over centuries.
King João III of Portugal (1502–1557) by Cornelis Anthonisz
Historyof Portuguese Classical Dressage
Portuguese Classical Dressage has its roots in the Iberian riding traditions of the Renaissance and Baroque periods.
It was heavily influenced by the teachings of classical masters such as François Robichon de La Guérinière, while also evolving through Portugal’s unique equestrian culture.
The Portuguese School of Equestrian Art continues to preserve and demonstrate these traditions today, typically using the Lusitano horse, a breed renowned for its natural balance, collection and willingness to work.
Modern riders also associate Portuguese Classical riding with legendary horseman Nuno Oliveira. Although Oliveira drew inspiration from both French and Portuguese traditions, his teachings have had a profound influence on riders around the world.
Core Philosophy
Portuguese Classical Dressage aims to develop a horse that is:
Balanced
Light
Responsive
Collected
Confident
Mentally relaxed
The partnership between horse and rider is considered just as important as technical correctness.
Collection is developed progressively through relaxation, balance and gymnastic training rather than force.
Key Training Principles
Portuguese Classical training commonly emphasises:
Balance before brilliance.
Lightness of the aids.
Self-carriage.
Early attention to collection appropriate to the horse’s development.
Lateral work.
Suppleness.
Rider feel and tact.
Harmony over mechanical precision.
The goal is to develop a horse that willingly carries itself while remaining calm and responsive.
Typical Characteristics
Training often includes:
Shoulder-in and travers.
Half-pass.
Renvers.
Collected work.
Transitions within and between gaits.
Work on circles.
Frequent attention to balance and straightness.
Progressive development of advanced movements.
Exercises are selected to improve the horse’s gymnastic ability rather than simply preparing for competition.
Strengths
Portuguese Classical Dressage offers many advantages:
Strong emphasis on rider feel.
Excellent development of balance and self-carriage.
Produces highly responsive horses.
Encourages harmony and relaxation.
Places significant value on the horse’s confidence and willingness.
Particularly well suited to agile breeds such as the Lusitano.
Many of its principles can benefit horses of all breeds.
Limitations
Some criticisms include:
The system is less standardised than the German approach.
It often relies heavily on experienced instruction which is not always easy to come by.
Some methods may be less familiar to riders trained exclusively within modern competition systems.
Certain training techniques are particularly suited to Iberian breeds and may require adaptation for other horse types.
These limitations reflect differences in emphasis rather than shortcomings of the philosophy itself.
Suitable Horses and Riders
Portuguese Classical Dressage appeals to riders who value:
Feel over force.
Harmony.
Collection.
Traditional horsemanship.
Long-term development.
Precision through softness rather than strength.
It is suitable for riders interested in both competitive dressage and classical riding.
Common Misconceptions
Portuguese Classical Dressage is sometimes viewed as relevant only to Lusitanos or working equitation.
In reality, its principles of balance, lightness and gymnastic development can be applied to horses of many breeds. While some techniques have evolved alongside Iberian horses, the underlying philosophy extends well beyond them.
How It Relates to Dressage Atlas
Dressage Atlas is primarily organised around the structured progression used in modern dressage. However, many of the exercises featured throughout the website, particularly those involving lateral work, balance and collection, are equally valuable within the Portuguese Classical tradition.
Understanding this philosophy provides riders with a broader appreciation of the different paths that can lead to a balanced, athletic and willing dressage horse.
Summary
Portuguese Classical Dressage combines centuries of Iberian horsemanship with classical principles of balance, lightness and collection. Through careful gymnastic development and refined communication, it aims to produce a horse that is confident, responsive and harmonious, making it an enduring and respected tradition within the world of dressage.